top of page
  • Writer's pictureSteve

The Benefits of Buying a Used Car Versus New

In the automotive world, the allure of a brand new car, with the latest features and that distinct new car smell, can be quite compelling. However, a deeper dive into the realm of pre-owned cars often reveals an attractive alternative. Purchasing a used car presents significant benefits, often overlooked in the dazzle of the new.

Line of cars at a used car dealership

From affordability and minimized depreciation, to lower insurance costs and the opportunity to own a model or make otherwise beyond one’s budget, the advantages are multifold. As we navigate the complexities of car ownership, our aim is to empower you with ample knowledge and insight, helping you to make a decision that best suits your circumstances and financial goals.

Benefits of Buying Used Cars

Jeep on white sands

While the benefits of buying a used car are quite persuasive and numerous, it's important to remember that this perspective is drawn from my personal experience and preferences. I confess that I may be somewhat biased in this debate, as in my 29 years of driving, I have yet to feel the thrill of driving off the dealership lot in a brand-new vehicle. However, my choices have always been made with a keen eye on achieving financial independence and getting the best value for my money.

The Cost Savings are One of the Biggest Benefits of Buying a Used Car

One of the most compelling reasons to opt for a used car is the substantial cost savings. When you purchase a new car, the moment it leaves the dealership, it experiences rapid depreciation. In fact, most new cars lose 20% of their value in the first year. This essentially means that your $30,000 car might only be worth $24,000 a year later. However, when you buy a used car, you let someone else take that initial depreciation hit. The cost you pay upfront is much lower, which is crucial if you're operating on a tight budget.

Man buying a used car at a dealership

Furthermore, the cost savings don't stop at the purchase price. It's typically cheaper to insure a used car, and in many states, the registration fees are lower for used cars as well, providing ongoing financial benefits. In addition, a used car could potentially allow you to step up to a nicer model than you might otherwise be able to afford. For example, the budget that could net you a base model new car might allow you to purchase a used luxury car.

In essence, buying a used car is like getting a fantastic deal on a slightly older model, with the added bonus of lower ongoing expenses. If you're budget-conscious and seeking financial independence, this is a strategy that could save you thousands and offer great value for your money.

The Price Difference: New vs Used Cars

When it comes to the cost difference between new and used cars, the statistics are quite revealing. According to Edmunds, a leading automotive information website, the average price of a new car in the United States in 2020 was a staggering $40,000, while the average cost of a used car hovered around $28,000.

Now, consider this - if you opt for a car that's one year old, it may still be within the manufacturer's warranty, with the latest safety features and modern conveniences, yet cost substantially less than its brand-new version. This fact alone could be a game-changer in the decision-making process for many.

Clean engine of a used car

Moreover, a study by iSeeCars analyzed 6.9-million car sales and found that, on average, buyers save 39.1% when they purchase a three-year-old, off-lease, used car instead of a new version of the same model. For some models, the savings can be even greater, up to a staggering 55.8% for a three-year-old Audi A6.

These numbers clearly illustrate the significant financial advantages of buying a used car. However, it's paramount to note that each car buying scenario is unique, and other factors like car condition, mileage, model availability, and personal preferences play a significant role in the decision-making process. Therefore, always consider multiple aspects and conduct a thorough analysis before taking the plunge.

Variety of Options

Another remarkable advantage of purchasing a used car is the sheer variety of options at your disposal. The used car market is like a treasure trove, abundant with a wide array of makes and models from different years, each with unique features and specs. While a new car dealership might offer several versions of the same model, the used car market expands those options exponentially, allowing you to select from a broader span of years, and thus a greater diversity of features, designs, and technological advancements.

AMG Mercedes with yellow racing stripe

For instance, if you have always longed for a classic Mustang or a discontinued model like a Hummer, the used car market is your only avenue. Moreover, it gives you the opportunity to own premium vehicles or luxury models, which might have been out of reach when new, but have now become affordable as used cars.

The used car market also gives you access to vehicles with a range of features that you may not be willing to pay for when buying new, such as higher-end trims, upgraded sound systems, leather interiors, or advanced safety features. This unprecedented variety not only caters to your individual preferences and requirements but also offers more room for negotiation, increasing the chances of getting a fantastic deal.

The Misconception of Reliability: Debunking the Myth

It's a common misconception that used cars are inherently less reliable than their newer counterparts. Many potential car buyers operate under the belief that a new car is synonymous with worry-free dependability, while a used car is a ticking time bomb of unexpected repairs. However, the data and research suggest otherwise.

Mechanic working on a car's engine

Today's vehicles are built to last. According to Consumer Reports, modern cars can function well over 100,000 miles with proper care and maintenance. Moreover, a report by IHS Markit states that the average age of cars on US roads is approximately 12.2 years.

Further dispelling the myth, the Annual Auto Reliability Survey by Consumer Reports showed that many used cars can prove to be reliable long-term investments. They found that several used models can be as reliable as their brand-new version, sometimes even more so, as initial kinks and recalls have been addressed.

Birdseye view of a mechanic working on a car

Maintenance costs for used cars have also seen a downturn. A study by YourMechanic shows that while maintenance costs do increase as the vehicle ages, the rate of this rise is not overly dramatic; an average 3-year old vehicle would cost about $450 in annual maintenance, while a 5-year old vehicle would be about $600 (according to their chart). The key lies in regular maintenance and taking care of minor issues before they escalate into major problems.

It's crucial to remember that not all used cars are created equal. A pre-owned vehicle with a well-documented maintenance history from a reputable source can be just as reliable, if not more so, than a new vehicle. Investing in a pre-purchase inspection can also go a long way in ensuring your potential used car is in top-notch condition.

Wrapping Up: The Road to Financial Independence Through Used Cars

The benefits of buying a used car are numerous. Not only does it present a financially savvy choice, but it also offers an unparalleled variety of options and a high degree of reliability. With the average cost of a used car significantly lower than a new one, military members seeking financial independence stand to gain enormously by opting for a pre-owned vehicle. This choice allows for substantial savings which can be redirected towards other financial goals.

The used car market also offers a plethora of choices, from classic models to luxury vehicles, allowing buyers to find a car that fits their personal preferences and budget. Moreover, the idea that used vehicles are less dependable is largely a myth; with proper care and maintenance, a used car can serve as a reliable mode of transportation for many years. Thus, for military members aiming for financial independence, purchasing a used car can be a strategic move that combines practicality, economy, and a sense of individuality.

Interior of a Mercedes Benz car

As you venture into your car buying journey, it's crucial to keep an open mind and consider each aspect carefully. Both new and used cars come with their own unique sets of advantages, and your decision should reflect your personal circumstances, preferences, and financial goals. Take your time to explore the sprawling used car market, where you may stumble upon an unexpected gem that perfectly aligns with your needs. Simultaneously, don’t dismiss the allure of a brand new vehicle, the smell of fresh upholstery, cutting-edge technology, and the assurance of a warranty. The decision is deeply personal and varies significantly based on individual requirements.

Remember, this guide is meant to inform and provide a perspective, not to dictate what your decision should be. The ultimate responsibility for your purchase decision lies with you. I'm simply here to equip you with the necessary knowledge and insights to make an informed choice. I cannot be held accountable for any decisions made or purchases completed based on this information. Happy car hunting and may you find the wheels that move not just your body, but also your spirit!


Commenting has been turned off.
bottom of page